COFFEE AND CRIME AU PODCAST
Explore Our Captivating Australian True Crime Case Archive

On a winter night in June 2014, police were called to a rural property in Western Australia. What began as an emergency response would later become the subject of a coronial inquest, forensic debate, and years of unanswered questions.

There is a sentence that appears repeatedly in discussions about Amy Wensley’s death: 'The scene had already changed.” Those six words sit at the centre of the controversy surrounding the investigation. They do not tell us how Amy died. They tell us something equally important: that later investigators were forced to examine a scene that was no longer preserved exactly as it had been at the critical moment.

On 1 March 1999, 15-year-old Rachel Elizabeth Barber disappeared from Melbourne, Victoria. Rachel was not just a name in a case file. She was a daughter, a sister, a friend, and a talented young dancer with her whole future ahead of her. She attended The Dance Factory in Richmond, where she was studying performing arts. Those who knew Rachel described her as a bright, caring and ambitious teenager who was passionate about dance.

Rachel Barber was just 15 years old. Talented, kind, and with a promising future ahead of her, she had no idea that someone she trusted had spent years becoming dangerously obsessed with her life. In this early access episode, we follow the case from the very beginning. From Rachel's final day at dance class and the fake psychology study that lured her to Caroline Reed Robertson's flat, to the calculated murder, the desperate attempts to conceal the crime, and the investig